Same Money, Same PAC

The RDP PAC, now called the Citizens for Quality School Leadership, was formed in 2016 and played a prominent role in 3 of the last 4 school board elections (see the table below). Most of the PAC’s money came from contractors who did business with the school corporation, the teachers union, and a community member who was appointed to a school board position on the West Lafayette library board. In the 2020 election, the RDP PAC claimed that the candidates they support were chosen by the teachers. This was a false claim; the teachers had no role in choosing the candidates the RDP PAC supported.

In my meeting summaries, I refer to current school board members Austin, Marley, Schott, and Witt as PAC members (PAC-supported school board members) because they were all supported by the PAC. Current school board members Mumford, Wang, and Yin have had no involvement with the PAC and so I refer to them as non-PAC members.

Campaign Year	PAC Name	PAC Leadership	Spending	Funding Source	PAC Candidates	Non-PAC Candidates
2016	RDP PAC	Chair: Brian Bittner Treasurer: Brad Marley	$4,125	IPACE – State Teachers Union Political Arm (Randy Studt)	Brad Marley, Tom Schott, Doug Masson, Brian Bittner	Melissa Prochnau
2020	RDP PAC	Chair: Dianne Sautter (originally Mayor John Dennis) Treasurer: Monica Shaeffer (recruited by Rachel Witt)	$24,159	IPACE – State Teachers Union Political Arm (Randy Studt) School Construction Architect (KJG) School Board Appointee (Atlschaeffl) School Board Members (Springer & Karpick) School Board Lawyer (Reiling) School Board Interim CFO (Sloat) School Board Consultant (Troyer) Others: Gregg Theobald, R Sutton, Mark Castell, Paul Brown, and Kelley & Pat Carr	Brad Marley, Tom Schott, Doug Masson, Amy Austin	Yue Yin, Dacia Mumford, David Purpura, Melissa Prochnau, Angie Janes, Sara Poer, William Watson, Brady Kalb, Jeff Kayser, Brian Ruh
2022	Citizens for Quality School Leadership	Chair: James Garland Treasurer: Joseph Krause	$4,000	$12,471.12 Transfer from RDP PAC	Rachel Witt, Karen Springer, George Lyle	Dacia Mumford, Laurence Wang, Angie Janes

The RDP PAC was formed in 2016 by school board members Brad Marley, Tom Schott, Brian Bittner, and Doug Masson with the assistance of a political consultant, Steve Klink. Their goal was to keep Melissa Prochnau from winning a seat on the school board as she was the only non-incumbent candidate in that election and the first non-incumbent to run for a WL school board seat since 2004. This is not one of those “super PACs” that are not allowed to coordinate with candidates. One of the candidates, Bittner, was the PAC chair, and another candidate, Marley, was the PAC treasurer. This PAC was lead by and coordinated with the candidates it supported. The PAC designed and paid for the yard signs for each of the supported candidates. The funding came from a $5,000 donation from the state teachers union political arm, I-PACE (Jr/Sr HS teacher Randy Studt is the state union leader who leads I-PACE). In addition to the yard signs, the PAC bought political advertising in the Journal & Courier and paid for direct mail political adverts. The PAC was unsuccessful in keeping Prochnau from being elected in 2016, though the vote was very close. Doug Masson lost his seat on the school board. There was little community awareness of the PAC after the 2016 election.

In 2020, there was widespread dissatisfaction with several recent school board decisions and 15 candidates ran for 4 school board seats. The RDP PAC reorganized to support the campaigns of Marley, Schott, Masson, and Amy Austin. West Lafayette Mayor John Dennis agreed to serve as chair of the PAC and current school board president Rachel Witt recruited Monica Shaeffer to serve as PAC secretary. One of the first things the PAC did was send out an “apocalyptic” letter which inflamed the community and was widely denounced, including by Mayor John Dennis who resigned as PAC chair. Notably, Rachel Witt defended the PAC and stood by the claims made in the letter. No one has come forward to accept responsibility for writing the letter. I don’t think it was any of the PAC candidates, but none of them has ever said who wrote it. A former school board member, Dianne Sautter, replaced Mayor Dennis as the PAC chair. The PAC raised $40,000 from companies that worked on the recent school construction projects, several other school contractors, the state teachers union, and a few other individuals including board members. The PAC spent $24,000 during the 2020 election. For comparison, a typical campaign for a school board candidate in our community spends around $1,000, primarily to buy yard signs. Much of the PAC’s massive amount of spending went to the Midwest Communications Group and First Tuesday Communications (political consultant Steve Klink’s company) and paid for direct mail political adverts, robo calls, and mass texts. In that election, the PAC was successful in getting 3 of the 4 PAC candidates (Marley, Schott, and Austin) elected (Masson lost for a 2nd time) with Yue Yin essentially replacing Prochnau as the lone non-PAC member of the school board.

There was a high level of community frustration with the RDP PAC after the 2020 election. So, in September 2022, the leaders of the RDP PAC transferred all its remaining assets to a new PAC called Citizens for Quality School Leadership (CQSL). This was just a renaming; the RDP PAC and the CQSL PAC list the same contact phone number and most importantly: it’s the same money. The PAC reported having spent $7,500 in the first part of the 2022 school board election supporting Witt, Springer, and Lyle. They again paid the Midwest Communications Group and an online advertising firm called El Toro. This time, the PAC was less successful, getting only 1 of the 3 PAC candidates (Witt) elected. After the election, they reported paying an additional $2,500 to Steve Klink’s First Tuesday Communications company and reported receiving a refund from the Midwest Communications Group. The PAC has $8,471 remaining in their account available to use in the 2024 election. Instead, I hope they will choose to donate this money to a good cause and keep PAC influence out of our community school board elections.

Current school board members Witt, Marley, Austin, and Schott were supported by the PAC. It’s also clear that Witt and Marley were involved in leading the PAC. There was obvious coordination between the candidates and the PAC in the 2016 and 2020 elections. Austin, Marley, Schott, and Masson never created their own campaign yard signs and instead had the PAC create and pay for their yard signs. Most of the people associated with the PAC are now trying to distance themselves from it. Their statements like “I don’t like the PAC,” “I am not the leader of the PAC,” and “I did not fill out the paperwork to create the PAC” do not contradict any of the facts given above.

You can follow the history of PAC through its financial filings (see links below). Claims that the CQSL PAC is entirely different from the RDP PAC are false. The financial filings make it clear that it’s the same money. Also below is a screenshot of the beginning of a Facebook post from the 2020 election where Witt states that she recruited Monica Shaeffer to serve as the PAC’s treasurer and notes that she supports the PAC.

2016 RDP PAC Creation

2016 RDP PAC End-of-year filing

2020 RDP PAC Reorganization

2020 RDP PAC Mid-election filing

2020 RDP PAC End-of-year filing

2021 RDP PAC End-of-year filing (shows no spending in 2021)